03 October 2021: Lab/In Vitro Research
Assessment of Color Stainability of Computer-Aided Design and Computer-Aided Manufacturing (CAD/CAM) Ceramic Materials After Hot and Cold Coffee Immersion at Different Time IntervalsHafiz A. Adawi 1A , Mohammed M. Al Moaleem 1ABE , Nasser M. Al Ahmari 2AG , Mansoor Shariff 2AF , Mohammed A. Qahhar 3G* , Sultan M.H. Muharraq 4BD , Nabiel A. Alghazali 56CDE
Med Sci Monit 2021; 27:e932745
BACKGROUND: This spectrophotometric study assessed the color stability of CAD/CAM restorative materials with different exposed surfaces following staining by hot Arabic Qahwa and cold coffee.
MATERIAL AND METHODS: Ninety-six specimens were fabricated from 3 different CAD/CAM ceramic materials: Vita Suprinity (Vita-S), Vita Enamic (Vita-E), and Vitablocs Mark II (Vitablocs-MII). We divided 32 specimens for each group into glazed or polished surfaces, with 16 specimens in each group, then subdivided them according to staining materials: Arabic Qahwa and Frappuccino Cold Coffee. Color of specimens was measured during immersion in staining materials (BEFORE) as baseline with (Vita classic) and (L, a, b), for average color changes (ΔE₀₀), then remeasured after 2, 4, and 12 weeks, and described as 1st, 2nd, and 3rd measurements for VITAPAN Classic shade and T1, T2, and T3 for ΔE00 values using the CIE L*a*b* equation. We performed ANOVA and then post hoc testing.
RESULTS: We found significant differences in ΔE₀₀ values during immersing in hot Arabic Qahwa and cold coffee for tested materials in glazed or polished specimens. Polished specimens of Vita-S and Vita-E had the highest color changing and staining compared to glazed surfaces. Vitablocs-MII had the best color stability through immersion periods. Moreover, there were changes in relation to VITAPAN Classic shade guide for both Vita-S and Vita-E specimens during different immersion periods.
CONCLUSIONS: Coffee caused staining and contamination of ceramic material. Values of ΔE₀₀ for tested ceramic materials were significantly different but were within the clinically acceptable range. Polished specimens showed higher staining; therefore, we highly recommend re-glazing of ceramic restorations to maintain color stability.
Keywords: Color, Staining and Labeling, VITA Suprinity
There is growing demand for highly esthetic restoration with better patient satisfaction and treatment success. Significant improvements in dental restorative materials and technology, such as computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing (CAD/CAM), have produced esthetic, affordable, efficient, and predictable restorations . The importance of CAD/CAM workflow is that it simplifies and integrates dental prostheses fabrication. Today CAD/CAM systems are increasingly used in dentistry. This technology allows a completely digital workflow, from impression to final framework, and the materials used showed excellent mechanical properties  and good precision . The restorative materials are pre-designed to be as a block, and the restoration will be milled out of it. The ceramic blocks are made as pre-sintered ceramic blocks. After milling, the restoration is fully centered at standardized parameters of pressure and temperature to achieve the desired mechanical and biological properties .
Earlier, the clinical performance of CAD/CAM ceramic restorative materials were unsatisfactory since they had short survival in the oral cavity. In 1991, Vita Mark II (Vita MII) was introduced to the market for better restoration mechanical properties. The blocks of VITA MII ceramic have fine constructed particles, and a different machining system to improve mechanical properties and strength . These blocks were monochromatic or available in multi-shade layers that permit a shade gradient as well as improved translucency [1,5,6]. Other brands of polymer-infiltrated ceramics and resin nano-ceramics, based on their contents, have improved material properties. For instance, it contained more resin, so they are soft and cause less damage to the opposing teeth and had low wear resistance because of the presence of nano- or macro-particles. In addition, they allow high surface smoothing with finishing and polishing procedures . The materials with higher ceramic content exhibited greater wear resistance, enhanced esthetic results, better biocompatibility, and high discoloration resistance [7,8].
The CAD/CAM technology was used to develop high-loading capacity hybrid ceramics, merging ceramic and glass polymers . Vita Enamic consists of 86% ceramic and 14% polymer by volume. Vita Suprinity is a zirconia-reinforced lithium silicate ceramic comprising 8–12% zirconium oxide, 56–64% silicone dioxide, and 15–21% lithium oxide. These materials are favored for their good mechanical properties [9,10].
Coffee can discolor materials and can be used to assess a materials’ tendency for discoloration . Dental ceramics, including CAD/CAM milled ceramics, are considered to have higher discoloration resistance. They show an excellent color match and high color stability during clinical use [12,13]. Visual color difference thresholds can be used as a quality control tool and guideline for selecting esthetic materials . However, some restorative and prosthetic materials in the oral cavity are exposed to changes in humidity and temperature, as well as being exposed to beverages, food, and smoking, which can cause extrinsic discoloration of these materials .
Arabic coffee (Qahwa Arabia) is a brew made of boiled coffee beans. Its color is light to dark brown, the taste can be plain or spicy, and it is served in a finjan, which is a small, handleless coffee cup. It can be consumed at any time of the day. For most families, gathering for Arabic coffee drinking has social and cultural importance . Coffee is claimed to have several health benefits . A recent study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine found that people who drink a cup of coffee a day were 12% less likely to die from cancer, stroke, diabetes, heart disease, kidney disease, and respiratory diseases . Coffee also has other health benefits, such as being calorie-free and containing antioxidants (eg, vitamin E) . However, there are still concerns that come with frequent drinking coffee. One of those concerns has to do with oral health; just one cup of coffee a day increases the risk of cavities. Additionally, coffee can contribute to halitosis or bad breath because of its strong smell, it increases oral bacteria in the mouth, and it causes different types of extrinsic tooth discoloration . Seyidaliyeva et al and Sarıkaya et al recorded an increase in the mean color changes of CAD/CAM restorative materials after coffee staining and immersions [20,21].
The CIE L* a* b* color system is used for the determination of color differences values [22–24]. The CIE-L* a* b* values are known as the “chromaticity coordinates”: (L*) value refers to “lightness”; the higher the L value, the greater the lightness. (a*) reveals red color on positive values and green color on negative values (−a*=green; +a*=red); (b*) shows yellow color on positive values and blue color on negative values (−b*=blue; +b*=yellow) [25,26]. The mean color differences values (ΔE00) were calculated with this equation:
Most patients are usually seeking aesthetic restorations like white teeth, and at the same time they are daily consuming a high quantity of the staining materials in the form of different types of coffee. The purpose of this in vitro study was to assess and compare the color stability of 3 CAD/CAM restorative materials (Vita Suprinity, Vita Enamic, and Vitablocs Mark II) with different exposed surfaces (glazed or polished) following exposure to staining with 2 different types of coffee drinks, and to record these changes on the basis of the VITAPAN Classical shade guide. The null hypotheses were: 1) There is no significant color change for every individual group after immersion in different types of coffee drinks compared to the original color evaluated with the VITAPAN Classical shade guide; 2) There is no significant difference in the overall average color changes (ΔE00) between different CAD/CAM restorative materials after staining with different types of coffee drinks; and 3) There is no significant effect of surface smoothing with glazing or polishing in color changes with coffee exposure.
Material and Methods
STUDY DESIGN: In this in vitro study, 96 specimens (shade B2) were constructed from 3 types of machinable CAD/CAM ceramic materials, then they were used to measure and evaluate the effect of 2 types of coffee and mean color changes of glazed or polished CAD/CAM ceramic materials at different time intervals. Furthermore, the change in color in relation to the VITAPAN Classical shade guide was also evaluated. Color measurements were done using a spectrophotometer (VITA Easyshade® V, VITA, Germany). Table 1 describes the supplied materials and devices used in this in vitro research. A diagram of the study design is shown in Figure 1. The sample sizes were calculated as 3 groups of 32 specimens per testing group, determined according to previously published studies [2,15]. The sample size was calculated with G* 85 Power software (version 3.1; University of Dusseldorf, Germany), with an effect size (d) of 1.4, α of 0.05, and 1-β (power) of 0.85. The effect size was calculated from the color changes of CAD/CAM specimens after beverage immersion at different time intervals.
A total of 96 specimens were manufactured from B2 Vita shade of 3 CAD/CAM restorative materials (32 specimens from each material): Vita Suprinity, Vita Enamic, and Vitablocs Mark II (Vita Zahnfabrik, H. Rauter, Bad Säckingen, Germany). The specimens were fabricated using a CAD/CAM machine (Amann Girrbach GmbH, Dürrenweg, Pforzheim, Germany). The blocks were installed on a milling machine to produce specimens of identical size and shape (16 mm in width and 2.0±0.1 mm thickness) for each ceramic material. Then, the specimens were sintered and glazed in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendation.
SPECIMENS SURFACE TREATMENTS AND WEIGHT MEASUREMENTS: The specimens of each group were then divided into 2 subgroups of 16 specimens each. The surfaces of one of the subgroups specimens was kept as glazed from the research laboratory and the other subgroup specimens were further polished with the Porcelain Adjustment Kit (SHOFU Dental ASIA-Pacific Pte. Ltd, Singapore) polishing kit. The proper arrangement of this kit is using the Dura-White Stones HP each CN1, FL3, and RE1 for adjusting and finishing, then Ceramisté Points HP each of KN7, PC2, and WH6 in standard, ultra, or ultra II grits for intraoral polishing of all ceramic prosthesis. The recommended average speed for Dura-White Stones is from 5000 to 20 000 rpm while the speed for Ceramisté Points is 10 000 to 12 000 rpm, using equal numbers of grindings in one direction with light, controlled pressure . Then, all specimens were measured using a VEVOR laboratory analytical balance (Schuler Scientific SLB-124, Milan, ITALY), and a Mettler Toledo Excellence XS 11106015 Model XS64 analytical balance, 61 g capacity, 0.1 mg. readability, and the measured weight was considered as the specimen’s weight before coffee staining and aging.
SPECIMENS COLOR CHANGE MEASUREMENTS WITH SPECTROPHOTOMETER: The 4 subgroups from each CAD/CAM ceramic restorative material group were transferred to colorimetric evaluation according to the CIE L*a*b* system. It was performed by a blind, trained operator immediately when it came from the laboratory as glazed or after surface treatments as polished, and this was considered as T0. Ahead of each measurement, the specimens were lightly washed with distilled water and air dried. Colors of the specimens were measured with a spectrophotometer (Vita Easyshade® Compact, Vita Zahnfabrik H. Rauter GmbH & Co. KG, Bad Säckingen, Germany) version V against a black background to mimic the absence of light in the mouth against a gray background. All specimens were chromatically assessed twice, and the average values were calculated by the above-mentioned equation; then, each color parameter for each specimen of the same shade was averaged as measured by previous studies [22–24]. In addition, the Vita Easy Shade Spectrophotometer Version V was used to record the color of the specimens according to the VITAPAN Classical shade guide before (baseline).
SPECIMENS STAINING WITH COFFEE AND SURFACE CONTAMINATION:
Following the baseline color assessments, the 16 samples of each individual subgroup were further divided, one half (8 samples) were stained in Arabic Qahwa, (Baja Food Industrial Co., Jeddah, Saudi Arabia) and the other half were stained in cold Frappuccino Coffee Drink (Arla Foods AMBA dk/8260 Viby J. Denmark) during the aging period. Instant Arabic hot Qahwa came in a nitrogen-flushed packet for single use. The staining solution prepared from each packet (30 g) was mixed with 0.5 L boiled water at 100°C, then kept boiling for 15 s. Starbucks Frappuccino cold coffee drinks are stored in a refrigerator and offered in sealed containers ready to use by shaking well before drinking. New coffee solutions were changed every 24 h. Following the aging process, all the specimens were dipped in distilled water 10 times, wiped with tissue paper, and left to completely air dry. During the immersion period, the color measurements of all samples were recorded after 2 (T1), 4 (T2), and 12 (T3) weeks. In addition, the shade of specimens was measured using the VITAPAN Classical shade guide (Vita classical Guide and Vita Bleached guide, Vita Zahnfabrik, Germany) (1st, 2nd, and 3rd) after 2, 4, and 12 weeks. Moreover, the color change (ΔE00) values were calculated by the above equation.
SCANNING ELECTRON MICROSCOPE CAPTURING: A single specimen from each type of tested material, glazed or polished, and from Arabic Qahwa and Frappuccino Coffee Drink were selected for scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to assess consistency of color changes. The samples were gold sputter coated (Figure 2) with Quorum® Q-150R (East Sussex, BN8 6BN United Kingdom). Then, the samples were loaded into the specimen’s stage of the JEOL® JSM-6610 LV (Akishima, Tokyo, Japan) scanning electron microscope using 20 kv and 500×magnification for scanning and photography. A diagram of the study design and steps of the study is shown in Figure 1.
Mean differences in color change (ΔE00) by the staining protocols were registered with Microsoft Excel 13 software, then data were calculated and analyzed using Statistical software Package for Social Science (SPSS) version 22.0 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago IL, USA). Descriptive statistics that involved mean and standard deviation (SD) values were determined for each CIE L*a*b* variable and the 4 subgroups of the VITAPAN Classical shade guide. The mean weight changes were calculated as the differences between pre- and -post values of weight. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and multiple comparison Bonferroni post hoc test were performed to determine whether there were any significant differences in the ΔE00 between and within the subgroups at
In relation to the mean values of the VITAPAN CLASSIC shade guide for Vita-S and Vita-E specimens at baseline shade (B2), at the first reading, both glazed and polished, either immersed in Arabic or cold coffee drink, the color of material had changed to C3 and C1. At the second reading and third readings, all the VITAPAN CLASSIC shade guide colors were changed to either A1, A2, B2, or a combination of each 2 colors. In the other hand, the Vitablocs-MII specimens remained as B2 throughout the 3 testing periods (Table 2).
The mean color changes ΔE00 values differences for the evaluated different ceramic materials with different surface smoothing and immersed in Arabic coffee were the highest at the T1, followed by values of ΔE00 at T2 and T3, respectively (Figure 3, Table 3). These results show reduction of the coffee contamination over time. There was a significant difference between and within the groups of ceramic stained by Arabic and with P value less than 0.050, except the ΔE00 (T3) of the polished Arabic coffee, which had a P value 0.714 (Table 3).
The mean color changes ΔE00 values differences for Vita-E and Vitablocs-MII with different surface smoothing and immersed in the cold coffee drink were the highest at T1, followed by T2, and T3 (Figure 3, Table 4). These results show reduction of the coffee contamination over time. The mean color changes ΔE00 values differences for Vita-S with different surface smoothing and immersed in the cold coffee drink were the highest at T3, followed by T2 and T1 (Figure 3, Table 4). These results show increased coffee contamination with cold coffee drink over time. There was a significant difference between and within the groups of ceramic stained by or cold coffee with P value less than 0.050 (Table 4).
The mean weight changes for all type of CAD/CAM ceramic materials in form of glazed or polished before and after staining with aging were between 0.110 and 0.619 mg. Furthermore, there were no significant differences between the groups and within the subgroups with P value ranging from 0.124 to 0.967, which were higher than 0.05 (Table 5). In addition, ANOVA showed no significant differences between and within all subgroups.
The SEM images showed scratch lines which were deeper in the glazed or polished cold coffee specimens of the Vita-S group in compared to the hot coffee specimens. Furthermore, Vita-E showed smoother surface texture with uniform dispersed small particles, whereas Vitablocs-MII specimens reveled uniform larger cluster filler particles protruding in some surfaces (Figure 2).
In the current study investigates the color changes and spectrophotometric analysis, the ΔE00 and color stainability of CAD/CAM restorative materials as zirconia-reinforced lithium silicate glass ceramic (Vita-S), hybrid glass ceramic blocks (Vita-E), and feldspathic ceramic blocks (Vitablocs-MII) with different exposed surfaces (glazed or polished) following immersion in hot or cold coffee. The first null hypothesis was partially rejected, because of there were changes in the mean color of Vita-S and Vita-E. The Vitablocs-MII specimens remains as the same color during the 3 different time intervals which has been extended into 12 weeks.
The value of ΔE00 is clinically important and challenging at different levels of color measurements. It has been shown that the borderline ΔE00 which is perceptible to all people in a color test is 2.5 [14,28]. So, identifying the value of ΔE00 that is perceptible or clinically acceptable is challenging, and different levels have been suggested [21,28–30]. Based on the previous studies, the ΔE00 values from 1 to 3.3 units considered as clinically acceptable, while ΔE00 values greater than 3.3 are considered to be clinically unacceptable [22,31–38]. Nevertheless, an in-vivo studies has presented the perceptible and clinically acceptable thresholds ΔE00 to be between 2.8 and 4.2 units [14,22,39].
Therefore, ΔE00 perceptible and clinically acceptable thresholds should be borne in mind when assessing color change spectrophotometrically. There were a significant and non-significant difference in the average color changes (ΔE00) between CAD/CAM restorative materials, surface type (glazed or polished), and coffee type (hot or cold), so the second null hypothesis were partially rejected and partially accepted. The overall ΔE00 values for the tested CAD/CAM restorative materials among specimens immersed in glazed hot coffee were between 0.86–3.04 for Vita-E and Vita-S, while the ΔE00 values for the polished specimens stained with hot coffee were between 1.02–2.9 for Vita-E, at the 3 different examined periods. In other hand, overall ΔE00 values for the glazed specimens immersed in cold coffee were between 1.16–3.69 for Vita-E and Vitablocs-MII, while it was between 1.04–3.36 for Vita-E for polished cold coffee at the 3 different examined periods. So, all the recorded ΔE00 values for the tested CAD/CAM restorative materials in both surfaces and coffee types were within the clinically acceptable range. For ΔE00 values recorded at the end of 2 weeks, our findings were similar to values of previous results conducted with glazed specimens immersed in hot coffee by Özyılmaz et al, and Abu-Obidah et al, for the 3 tested types [35,40]; Aydın et al, for Vita-S and Vita-E ; and Colombo et al, as well as Quek et al, for Zirconia and Vita-E, respectively [15,42]. Among, the polished samples immersed in cold coffee in this study, the ΔE00 values recorded were coincided with values documented by Abu-Obidah et al, for the 3 tested types ; Sarıkaya et al, for Vita-E, and Al Moaleem et al, for Vitablocs-MII and zirconia [21,34]. In other hand for glazed cold drink, the ΔE00 values in the current study were in parallel with results of Quek et al, , those stained their Vita-E samples with cold red wine and Coca Cola, and similar with Sarıkaya et al, and Sagsoz et al, [21,30], those immersed their polished Vita-E CAD/CAM restorative material specimens in cold drinks. Contritely, the overall obtained ΔE00 values were lesser than scores gained by Saba et al, and Jian et al, those documented a ΔE00 values were above the clinically accepted rang ≥3.7 [32, 43].
Glazing is the most popular surface finishing steps for ceramic prostheses. Many studies concluded that glaze layer was superior to other polishing systems in relations to surface characteristics and staining resistance [14,34,44]. Furthermore, several studies [20–21,25,29–31,42–46], had specified that glazed ceramic prostheses have shown a reduced amount of discoloration than mechanically polished prostheses. In the current study, the ΔE00 values for the glazed specimens after 2 weeks immersion in an instant-hot-Arabic Qahwa (T1) were 1.98; 3.04; 2.87 for Vita-S, Vita-E, and Vitabloc-MII, respectively. While the ΔE00 values for the polished specimens after the same immersion period in hot-Arabic Qahwa (T1) were 2.42, 2.90, 2.79 for Vita-S, Vita-E, and Vitabloc-MII, respectively. All these color differences were within the clinical acceptable range which demonstrates that the polishing procedures and protocols used in this study were effective in achieving very smooth surface that got experience acceptable color change compared to glazed samples. This agreed with some previous studies assured that some porcelain polishing kits and protocols may be comparable to glazing [30,40,47]. The polishing kit which has specifically preferred assortment of white stones and porcelain polishers for chairside correction and glaze-like polishing of porcelain restorations prior or after cementation. Also, the set is indispensable in the dental research laboratory for very fine corrections of porcelain restorations and successive high-gloss polishing. In addition, kit helps eliminate the tedious re-firing process, saves time by avoiding the restoration being sent to the laboratory for re-glazing, which may affect the ceramic color and prevents the inconvenience of a recall appointment for the patient. Finally, it is essential in the dental research laboratory for very fine improvements of CAD/CAM prosthesis and creates a successive high-gloss polishing.
It is important to point out that this study was evaluated the daily used beverage in our live and it is known to have the potential to stain prosthetic and restorative restorations. In relation to the Frappuccino coffee cold drink, the ΔE00 values were the highest at the T1 (3.69 and 3.36) for glazed and polished Vita-E, and 3.36 Vitablocs-MII, respectively, followed by T2, while the lowest values were at T3 (1.04 and 1.21) for polished specimens of Vita-E and Vitablocs-MII with significant differences between CAD/CAM restorative materials at 4 weeks’ time intervals with p value >0.001. Aydın et al, measured the ΔE00 among Vita-E and Vita-S after 4-weeks immersion in different beverage staining drinks . They recorded ΔE00 values in relation to glazed Vita-E ceramics were 2.31 for coffee, 6.46 for wine, and 0.0.51 for Coca Cola drinks, but for glazed Vita-S, the values were 2.27 for coffee, 6.05 for wine, and 0.69 for Coca Cola. Those values are much higher than our ΔE00 values especially for wine drinks, but it agreed in the values of glazed samples stained by coffee in both examined CAD/CAM restorative materials, with significant differences for glazed coffee group . Arocha et al, recorded ΔE00 for coffee after 4 weeks immersion for hybrid ceramic (Lava Ultimate) in form of glazed (control group) 1.79, for immersed in coffee 14.21, which somewhat at higher values than our findings . This was already illustrated and agreed that he progressive staining of the ceramic materials was visually observed by the end of the 14-day period after coffee immersions [20,48]. These results will advise that we should, as much as we can, instruct the patients not to eat or drink any discoloration materials in the first 2 weeks after placing any aesthetic ceramic restoration.
Significant differences and the lowest ΔE00 values after 12 weeks for all examined CAD/CAM restorative materials, with ΔE00 ranged from 0.86 to 1.41 for glazed Vita-S and Vitablocs-MII, but it was 1.02 to 1.15 for polished specimens of Vita-E and Vitablocs-MII after immersion in hot Arabic Qahwa. Those values were lesser in comparing to values recorded by Alghazali et al, for both glazed feldspathic or zircon specimens or 4.23 and 4.34 for polished feldspathic and zircon specimens immersed in Arabic Qahwa . Also, current study values were in matching with values of Alharbi et al, whose demonstrated that staining caused by glazed or polished Vita-E blocks results after red wine immersion in compared to hot coffee after 120-day staining . Specimens of Vita-S recorded ΔE00 values 2.81 and 4.08 for glazed or polished after immersion in coffee and other beverages . Jain et al, after 90 days of staining, they reported a ΔE00 values of 7.13, 5.80, and 4.73 for hot coffee, cold Coca Cola, and cold orange juice, respectively. Those values are much higher than values recorded in the present study, this could be explained by that ceramic samples used by Jain et al, were manually prepared and condensed over a layer of metal alloy, while our specimens were fabricated by milling machine and were metal free . The values of polished samples were much lesser and ranging from 1.04 to 1.15 for Vita-S and Vita-E with no significant at the 3 months’ time interval with P value 0.714 .
To correlate the results of this spectrophotometric in vitro laboratory study with the in-vivo clinical situation, we created on the following scenario: If 1-day storage would equal to 1-month consume of staining solutions, the 2-week storage used during in vitro immersion would correspond to 1 year and 2 months in an in-vivo clinical setting . In other way specimens were immersed in different staining solutions for 1 month should be equivalent to about 2.5 years of oral cavity survive . This mean the 3 months interval for this in vitro immersion period is equal to 10 years of the survival rate of the CAD/CAM restorative materials in oral cavity. Other researchers suggested that immersion in coffee for one week was equivalent to 7 months of coffee drinking with the assumption that the coffee persisted in the mouth throughout drinking . Thus, 4 weeks immersion of specimens in staining materials for calculation of the consequent staining outcome might be an exaggeration of the truth.
Regarding to VITAPAN CLASSIC shade guide (B1), the Vita-S and Vita-E were changed into C3 and C1, (darker color) after 2-weeks staining, while after 4 weeks and 12 weeks the color returned back to the lighter colors “A1, A2, B2 or a combination of each 2 colors”. Parallel findings were recorded by Derafshi et al, those demonstrated significant differences and changing into darker color after 24 hours, but into lighter color of zirconia and e.max samples after 72 h and 7 days of immersions in chlorhexidine mouth wash . Al Moaleem et al observed changes in the VITAPAN CLASSIC shade guide of different glazed or polished feldspathic metal ceramic samples as VMK MSSTER (90%), followed by 70% for VMK 95, and less than half (40%) for VMK VM13 type after 1-week immersion in khat extract , but in the present study no changes were recorded for glazed or polished Vitablocs-MII feldspathic CAD/CAM ceramic materials immersed in hot or cold coffee. This will suggest and assure that feldspathic ceramic is still the least in color change and color stability as it has no glass filler which will always keep the surface smooth enough even after polishing protocols. Therefore, we suggest utilizing feldspathic ceramic wherever possible for our aesthetic treatments.
There are various factors causing color changes in restorations, as plaque accumulation, pigmentation effect of staining and immersion materials, dehydration, water absorption, surface roughness, and chemical degradation . Even though the Vita-E CAD/CAM restorative material consists primarily of 66% by weight hydrophobic urethane dimethacrylate (UDMA) and 33% by weight hydrophilic triethylene glycol dimethacrylate (TEGDMA), and water uptake by Bis GMA-based resins increased from 3 to 6% as the proportion of TEGDMA was increased from 0 to 1%, respectively. Accordingly, the high weight% of TEGDMA in Vita-E blocks may have resulted in greater water sorption which may have permitted the penetration of any hydrophilic colorant into the resin matrix . In addition, to that the ceramic materials are hydrophilic, but no significant different among the tested CAD/CAM restorative materials were recorded in the weight of the samples after 12 weeks of aging and immersion in hot or cold coffee. This was coincided with those said that there was no significant correlation or differences between ΔE00 for Vita-E, Vitablocs-MII, and conventional restorative resin blocks and water sorption or solubility after immersion for a period of time . Zidan et al, stated that sorption in distilled water or artificial saliva for groups containing zirconia showed sorption values lower than the control group at 90 and 180 days without significant differences in comparison to the control group . Since the pH of hot or cold coffees are recognized to equivalent to 5.4, this might cause higher sorption values were knowledgeable in materials wrapped up in solutions with pH extending between 4 and 6 .
The clinical relevance for studying of prosthetic materials are to guide, help, and support the dental clinicians or practitioners and dental technicians. Also, to estimate the color stability of commonly used dental restorative materials and the effect of glazing and polishing in removal or elimination of discolorations and extrinsic discolorations . The present report evaluated discoloration under ideal conditions. However, many variables could have an influence on the results of the present report. In fact, some variables such as brushing , or wear  could have a significant effect in surface characteristics of dental materials. These factors could also influence color conditions. Therefore, this can consider as a limitation, and an additional report are needed in order to confirm the results of the present report. Further in-vitro and in-vivo studies are necessary to evaluate the susceptibility of other CAD/CAM restorative materials staining by other beverages and nutrients.
This in vitro spectrophotometric color change study reached the following conclusions.
FiguresFigure 1. A diagram showing the design of the study and sequences of research steps. Figure 2. Representative SEM image of tested CAD/CAM materials “Vita Suprinity, Vita Enamic, and Vitablocs Mark II” at ×250 magnification after staining and aging. Figure 3. Mean and SD values of color changes of different type of ceramic at different time intervals in relation to surface type and staining materials.
TablesTable 1. Materials and devices used in the study [8–10]. Table 2. Mean and SD of the ΔE00 for ceramic materials stained by Arabic coffee. Table 3. Mean and SD of the ΔE00 for ceramic martials stained by cold coffee drink. Table 4. Mean and SD of the weight changes values parameter in each tested subgroup. Table 5. Comparison in color changes between basic colors of VITABAN Classical shade guide and the tested specimens after staining with coffee at different time intervals.
1. Giordano R: Materials for chairside CAD/CAM-produced restorations: J Am Dent Assoc, 2006; 137; S14-21
2. Colombo M, Poggio C, Lasagna A: Vickers micro-hardness of new restorative CAD/CAM dental materials: Evaluation and comparison after exposure to acidic drink: Materials (Basel), 2019; 12(8); 1246
3. Erozan Ç, Ozan O: Evaluation of the precision of different intraoral Scanner-Computer Aided Design (CAD) software combinations in digital dentistry: Med Sci Monit, 2020; 26; e918529
4. Lambert H, Durand J-C, Jacquot B, Fages M: Dental biomaterials for chairside CAD/CAM: State of the art: J Adv Prosthodont, 2017; 9(6); 486-95
5. Giti R, Haghdoost S, Ansarifard E: Effect of different coloring techniques and surface treatment methods on the surface roughness of monolithic zirconia: Dent Res J, 2020; 17; 152-61
6. Nasr E, Makhlouf AC, Zebouni E, Makzoumé J: All-ceramic computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing restorations: Evolution of structures and criteria for clinical application: J Contemp Dent Pract, 2019; 20(4); 516-23
7. Russe ND, Sadoun MJ: Resin-composite blocks for dental CAD/CAM applications: J Dent Res, 2014; 93; 1232-34
8. Blatz MB: Long-term clinical success of all-ceramic posterior restorations: Quintessence Int, 2002; 33; 415-26
9. Cetindemir AB, Sermet B, Ongul D: The effect of light sources and CAD/CAM monolithic blocks on degree of conversion of cement: J Adv Prosthodont, 2018; 10; 291-99
10. Riquieri H, Monteiro JB, Viegas DC: Impact of crystallization firing process on the microstructure and flexural strength of zirconia-reinforced lithium silicate glass-ceramics: Dent Mater, 2018; 3; 1483-91
11. Kim JH, Lee YK, Powers M: Influence of a series of organic and chemical substances on the translucency of resin composites: J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater, 2006; 77; 21-27
12. Watts A, Addy M: Tooth discoloration and staining: A review of the literature: Br Dent J, 2001; 190; 309-16
13. Choi MS, Lee YK, Lim BS: Changes in surface characteristics of dental resin composites after polishing: J Mater Sci Mater Med, 2005; 16; 347-53
14. Paravina RD, Ghinea R, Herrera LJ: Color difference thresholds in dentistry: J Esthet Restor Dent, 2015; 27; S1-S9
15. Colombo M, Cavallo M, Miegge M: Color stability of CAD/CAM Zirconia ceramics following exposure to acidic and staining drinks: J Clin Exp Dent, 2017; 9(11); 1297-303
16. Bamia C, Cornelis M:: The impact of caffeine and coffee on human health, 2019; Printed Edition of the Special Issue Published in Nutrients
17. Wolde T: Effects of caffeine on health and nutrition: A review: Food Science and Quality Management, 2014; 30; 59-65
18. Namboodiripad PCA, Kori S: Can coffee prevent caries?: J Conserv Dent, 2009; 12(1); 17-21
19. Al Moaleem MM, Porwal A, Al Ahmari NM: Khat Chewing induces a floral shift in dental material-associated microbiota: A preliminary study: Med Sci Monit, 2020; 26; e918219
20. Seyidaliyeva A, Dipl-Ing SR, Evagorou Z: Color stability of polymer-infiltrated-ceramics compared with lithium disilicate ceramics and composite: J Esthet Restor Dent, 2020; 32; 43-50
21. Sarıkaya I, Yerliyurt K, Hayran Y: Effect of surface finishing on the color stability and translucency of dental ceramics: BMC Oral Health, 2018; 18; 40
22. Alghazali N, Burnside G, Moallem M: Assessment of perceptibility and acceptability of color difference of denture teeth: J Dent, 2012; 40; e10-17
23. Alghazali N, Hakami AA, AlAjlan GA: Influence of the arabic-coffee on the overall color of glazed or polished porcelain veneersstudy: Open Dent J, 2019; 13; 364-70
24. Della Bona A, Kelly JR: The clinical success of all-ceramic restorations: J Am Dent Assoc, 2008; 139; 8S-13S
25. Acar O, Yilmaz B, Altintas SH: Color atainability of CAD/CAM and nanocomposite resin materials: J Prosthet Dent, 2013; 115; 71-75
26. Shiozawa M, Takahashi H, Asakawa Y, Iwasaki N: Color stability of adhesive resin cements after immersion in coffee: Clin Oral Investig, 2015; 19; 309-17
27. Al-Moaleem MM, Shah FK, Khan NS, Porwal A: The effect of thermocycling on the bonding of different restorative materials to access opening through porcelain fused to metal restorations: J Adv Prosthodont, 2011; 3; 186-89
28. Silva FB, Vilela ARA, Almeida MM: Surface topography, gloss and flexural strength of pressable ceramic after finishing-polishing protocols: Braz Dent J, 2019; 30(2); 164-70
29. ALGhazali N, Laukner J, Burnside G: An investigation into the effect of try-in pastes, uncured and cured resin cements on the overall color of ceramic veneer restorations: An in vitro study: J Dent, 2010; 38(Suppl 2); e78-86
30. Sagsoz O, Demirci T, Demirci G: The effects of different polishing techniques on the staining resistance of CAD/CAM resin-ceramics: J Adv Prosthodont, 2016; 8; 417-22
31. Stawarczyk B, Sener B, Trottmann A: Discoloration of manually fabricated resins and industrially fabricated CAD/CAM blocks versus glass-ceramic: Effect of storage media, duration, and subsequent polishing: Dent Mater J, 2012; 31; 377-83
32. Saba DA, Salama RA, Haridy R: Effect of different beverages on the color stability and microhardness of CAD/CAM hybrid vs feldspathic ceramic blocks: an in vitro study: Future Dent J, 2017; 3; 61-66
33. Al-Moaleem MM, Homeida HE, Dafalla OM: Evaluation of color changes and surface topography of different feldspathic ceramic materials after immersion in khat catha edulis extract: Bioscence Biotechnology Research Communnications, 2020; 13(1); 160-68
34. Al Moaleem MM, AlSanosy R, Al Ahmari NM: Effects of khat on surface roughness and color of feldspathic and zirconia porcelain materials under simulated oral cavity conditions: Medicina, 2020; 56; 234-47
35. Özyılmaz OY, Özel GS, Ahmet BS: Effects of glazing procedures on the color stability of conventional and CAD/CAM hybrid ceramics: A comparative study: Meandros Med Dent J, 2019; 20; 209-18
36. Sarikaya I, Güler AU: Effects of different surface treatments on the color stability of various dental porcelainsy: J Dent Science, 2011; 6(2); 65-71
37. Sarikaya I, Güler AU:: ISO/TR 28642 dentistry – guidance on color measurement, 2011
38. Pérez MM, Ghinea R, Herrera LJ: Dental ceramics: A CIEDE2000 acceptability thresholds for lightness, chroma and hue differences: J Dent, 2011; 39(Suppl 3); e37-44
39. Douglas RD, Steinhauer TJ, Wee AG: Intraoral determination of the tolerance of dentists for perceptibility and acceptability of shade mismatch: J Prosthet Dent, 2007; 7(4); 200-8
40. Abu-Obaid A, AlMawash A, Alyabis N, Alzaaqi N: An in vitro evaluation of the effect of polishing on the stainability of different CAD/CAM ceramic materials: Saudi Dent J, 2020; 32; 135-41
41. Aydın N, Karaoğlanoğlu S, Oktay EA, Kılıçarslan MA: Investigating the color changes on resin-based CAD/CAM Blocks: J Esthet Restor Dent, 2020; 32(2); 251-56
42. Quek SHQ, Yap AUJ, Rosa V: Effect of staining beverages on color and translucency of CAD/CAM composites: J Esthet Restor Dent, 2018; 30; e9-e17
43. Jain C, Bhargava A, Gupta S: Spectrophotometric evaluation of the color changes of different feldspathic porcelains after exposure to commonly consumed beverages: Eur J Dent, 2013; 7; 172-80
44. Abdalkadeer HK, Almarshedy SM, Al Ahmari NM: Influence of the Coca-Cola drinks on the overall color of glazed or polished porcelain veneers fabricated from different materials and thicknesses: An in vitro study: J Contemp Dent Pract, 2020; 21(1); 56-61
45. Motro PFK, Kursoglu P, Kazazoglu EE: Effects of different surface treatments on stainability of ceramics: J Prosthet Dent, 2012; 108; 231-37
46. Derafshi R, Khorshidi H, Kalantari M, Ghaffarlou I: Effect of mouthrinses on color stability of monolithic zirconia and feldspathic ceramic: An in vitro study: BMC Oral Health, 2017; 17; 129
47. Arocha MA, Basilio J, Llopis J: Colour stainability of indirect CAD-CAM processed composites vs. conventionally laboratory processed composites after immersion in staining solutions: J Dent, 2014; 42(7); 831-38
48. Lauvahutanon S, Shiozawa M, Takahashi H: Discoloration of various CAD/CAM blocks after immersion in coffee: Restor Dent Endod, 2017; 42(1); L9-18
49. Alharbi A, Ardu S, Bortolotto T, Krejci I: Stain susceptibility of composite and ceramic CAD/CAM blocks versus direct resin composites with different resinous matrices: Odontology, 2017; 105; 162-69
50. Zidan S, Silikas N, Haider J, Yates J: Long-term sorption and solubility of zirconia-impregnated PMMA nanocomposite in water and artificial saliva: Materials, 2020; 13; 373-43
51. Scribante A, Vallittu P, Lassila LVJ: Effect of long-term brushing on deflection, maximum load, and wear of stainless steel wires and conventional and spot bonded fiber-reinforced composites: Int J Mol Sci, 2019; 20(23); 6043
52. Gwon B, Bae EB, Lee JJ: Wear characteristics of dental ceramic CAD/CAM materials opposing various dental composite resins: Materials (Basel), 2019; 12(11); 1839
13 October 2021 : EditorialEditorial: Global Initiatives Support the Use and Regulation of Digital Health Technology During the COVID-...
Med Sci Monit In Press; DOI: 10.12659/MSM.935123
11 October 2021 : Clinical ResearchClinical Features and Temporal Lung Radiographic Changes in 25 Patients Recovering from COVID-19 Pneumonia:...
Med Sci Monit In Press; DOI: 10.12659/MSM.933381
08 September 2021 : Clinical ResearchAcceptance of COVID-19 Vaccination and Its Associated Factors Among Cancer Patients Attending the Oncology ...
Med Sci Monit In Press; DOI: 10.12659/MSM.932788
13 Oct 2021 : EditorialEditorial: Global Initiatives Support the Use and Regulation of Digital Health Technology During the COVID-...
Med Sci Monit In Press; DOI: 10.12659/MSM.935123
13 Oct 2021 : Clinical ResearchEndovascular Repair of Thoracic Aorta Injury: 17 Years of Single-Center Experience
Med Sci Monit In Press; DOI: 10.12659/MSM.934479
11 Oct 2021 : Clinical ResearchChallenges for Polish Community Pharmacists in Provision of Services to Immigrants and Non-Polish-Speakers ...
Med Sci Monit In Press; DOI: 10.12659/MSM.933678
Most Viewed Current Articles
20 Mar 2020 : Clinical ResearchSocial Capital and Sleep Quality in Individuals Who Self-Isolated for 14 Days During the Coronavirus Diseas...
Med Sci Monit 2020; 26:e923921
15 Apr 2020 : Clinical ResearchPsychological Impact and Coping Strategies of Frontline Medical Staff in Hunan Between January and March 20...
Med Sci Monit 2020; 26:e924171
05 May 2020 : Review articleAn Evidence Based Perspective on mRNA-SARS-CoV-2 Vaccine Development
Med Sci Monit 2020; 26:e924700